Why Do We Write: Autonomy, Mastery, Purpose

Wednesday, December 14, 2011
I just received a quarterly royalty statement and it wasn't stellar. The money just isn't there. Why do I keep doing this, writing for kids and writing how-to-write articles and books? Why do we keep working in the face of surprisingly little money?

I've been reading DRIVE: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us by Daniel H. Pink. He says that business has traditionally been built on the idea of carrots and sticks. If you do well, we'll reward you (with money, fame, perks, etc), and if you do poorly, we'll punish you. Unfortunately, the carrots and sticks approach works best for routine jobs and only for those type jobs. Think assembly lines. For those jobs where you want something done exactly the same each time, where compliance to a strict method is important, use the rewards and punishments system.

Writing is seldom a routine job. Instead, for work like ours, Pink says we are motivated by three things: autonomy, mastery and purpose.

Writers certainly have autonomy. For fiction at least, we often write on spec, or the speculation that someone might like what we write. We determine the audience we will target, topics we'll discuss, the characters we'll create. We decide when we write, how we write and what editors/publishers we work with. Everything about a writing career is autonomous.

A second motivator is mastery, spending time to become an expert. When you are engaged in a subject, totally fascinated and you find that time stands still while you write, then you are working toward mastery. Pink describes this altered state as being in "the flow." In fact the best predictor of productivity is the desire for intellectual challenge, "the urge to master something new and engaging."

A sense of purpose is the final motivator and it's a powerful one. People who champion a cause are more likely to be engaged and to work with autonomy. Even brief reminders of a purpose behind your work is enough to increase productivity. My purposes revolve around two things: creating great literature for kids and helping other writers to reach their potential. When one of those purposes is activated in a piece of writing, I am willing to work harder--regardless of the results on that royalty statement.

Ours is a profession that thrives on autonomy, mastery and purpose. Do I want money? Yes! But oddly enough, Pink recommends business people provide adequate monetary incentive--make sure people can take care of their family and commitments. After that baseline is met, increasing pay doesn't increase productivity much; instead, an environment that encourages autonomy, mastery and purpose will increase productivity.

Why do I keep writing in the face of less-than-stellar royalty statement? Because I'm doing what I want, when I want; I am engaged and fascinated by this process of putting words on the page; and I do it for the kids and for other writers. I love my job. That's why I write.

Author and writing teacher Darcy Pattison blogs at Fiction Notes (www.darcypattison.com).


Angela Mackintosh said...

Hi Darcy,

Insightful post! I have to check out Drive. I've heard a lot of good things about it. I think if we all follow our passions and be true to ourselves many good things will come (including money!). It may take time but ultimately it's worth it.

Welcome aboard! :)

Margo Dill said...

I write for the same reasons, Darcy! :) I have recently been thinking: should I give in? Should I go get at least a part-time job in the corporate world, writing for businesses? I think I'm impatient. I have three books coming out within the next couple years, so things seem to finally be picking up. But some days it's hard, and it's harder when you are staying at home with a 1-year-old, too. But the autonomy is so wonderful! And the purpose keeps me going--that and I don't want to miss a minute of my goofy girl wandering around our living room, singing and carrying baskets and purses! :) Thanks for an insightful post.

Patricia Bailey said...

I love Drive - refer to it in my regular work often. As for purpose - I just pulled your Novel Metamorphosis off my shelf to guide me through a novel revision. Me and my soon to be great novel thank you :-)


Great post. I like to write and I like to garden. Both of these hobbies can turn into business. But lucrative business? Probably not. So I'm not quitting my day job anytime soon.

Anonymous said...

Great post! Glad to have you blogging for The Muffin. :)

Anonymous said...

That was Marcia P above, not "anonymous!"

Amanda K Jaros said...

How great! I just posted on my blog today Why I write. Great minds think alike I guess. I'm intrigued to read the book you mention. Sounds interesting. Thanks for the insightful post:)

Anonymous said...

Great post! So true! I still contract illustration work and it's not huge bucks either - but the autonomy is the reason. Every day I ask "How can I get better at this craft?" I don't know if everyone out there needs or wants to ask that question daily. It's a motivator.

Darcy Pattison said...

Hope Novel Metamorphosis helps! That's my purpose. : )

Nice post about why you write. Reads like a litany.

Yes, lots of us work to be better at our creative efforts and that question--How can I get better at this craft--is indeed a powerful force.

Glad to be here at WOW!


Bobbi Miller said...

What a wonderful writing, Darcy! Thank you for reminding me why I write!

LuAnn Schindler said...

Yeah, the autonomy is a decent reward, but for me, the motivation and mastery offer such a great payback...and open so many more doors!!

Glad to have you here with us at The Muffin! :)

Powered by Blogger.
Back to Top